Oklahoma School District Bans Five-Year-Old From Wearing Michigan Shirt

Five-year-old Cooper Barton may have violated Oklahoma City Schools dress code, but he is the biggest little U-M fan in Oklahoma.

One of the more touchy subjects for public school districts always seems to be their dress code. When setting policy, they have to try and walk a fine line between freedom of expression and bad taste, or even indecency. Dress codes are usually a work in progress, as they have to deal with new trends in fashion, political statements, and a whole host of other issues these days.

Regardless of how a school district decides, they always manage to anger some folks. For whatever reason, these debates always seem to fire people up on both sides of the issue, and the discourse never fails to get ugly. It is most often, a lose/lose issue for administrators.

I have a certain amount of empathy for school districts who responsibly try to find the proper balance in their dress code policies, but I have also found some to be completely disgraceful in overstepping their bounds, with stupid interpretations of said policies.

This brings me to Cooper Barton. Cooper is five years old, and is a student at Wilson Elementary School in Oklahoma City. He wore a University of Michigan t-shirt to his kindergarten class one day. In doing so, he became a violator of the Oklahoma City Public Schools' dress code policy.

Apparently, he violated a part of the dress code that was created with the help of an "anti-gang task force." It seems that national gangs often use sports gear to represent local gangs. Or something like that.

The official dress code policy that Cooper ran afoul of, prohibits clothing bearing the names or emblems of all professional and collegiate athletic teams (with the exception of Oklahoma colleges and universities.)

Cooper is five years old. What gang could this child actually be involved with? Could he be involved with suspicious gang activity involving the stealing of straws from other students' little milk cartons? Or worse yet, could they be switching up the chocolate from the regular milk? Finger-painting gang graffiti on their desks? The list of possibilities is endless.

So once Cooper was identified as a dress code violator, Cooper was forced by the principal to turn his shirt inside out for the rest of the day. This was the reasoned thinking of the senior administrator of the school. Take a five-year-old kindergartner, and make him wear his shirt inside out for the rest of the day.

I wonder how his classmates reacted to this? I wonder if this kindergarten class teased him for getting in trouble, or maybe they thought it was as ridiculous as the rest of the country thinks it is? I have heard that Cooper even received messages of support from Ohio State folks. If that doesn't clinch it in his favor, nothing will.

The smart school district allows their administrators some wiggle room for interpretation in these types of policies. The reasonable teacher or principal understands that Mom and Dad are probably U-M fans, or alumni and may be from Michigan. They understand that the child probably got the shirt as a gift from a relative in Michigan (which is indeed the case).

They understand that Cooper is not a gang banger, and therefore, his shirt is not a threat to student safety. The sensible person allows logic to prevail, and it is obvious that nobody involved with this fiasco was either smart, nor sensible, and now they have egg on their faces.

And now, (In my very best Paul Harvey voice) here's the rest of the story.

Cooper's plight came to the attention of the University of Michigan Athletic Director David Brandon. He is a disciple of the Bo Schembechler rules of right and wrong. He saw the idiocy of the situation, and he took action.

The first thing he did, was to have his folks design and make a t-shirt for Cooper that displays the U-M logo even when it is turned inside-out. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9b-1adg-ys8

The next thing he did was to give Cooper a phone call, and invite the boy and his family up this year for a game at the Big House, so that U-M can introduce him to 110,000 new friends, as the biggest Meechigan fan in the state of Oklahoma. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZerqGERXVk

Cooper and family gladly accepted that invitation.

These are the actions of a sensible person. These are the actions of a man that wants to see something good come out of something bad. These are the actions of a school that most likely will have a future student, and who knows, maybe an athlete. If nothing else, the University of Michigan Wolverines have probably gained a fan for life.

Have fun at your football game Cooper, and GO BLUE!!!

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Jen August 28, 2012 at 10:08 PM
Parents are typically made aware of dress codes well before the school year starts. It's strictly in the dress code and the parents should have made sure their child followed the dress code. Sure they could make exceptions but then where DO they draw the line? What grade would be acceptable to start implementing this policy? It's not like the policy was vague, it was pretty up front and clear that this was unacceptable dress code for the school district and the parents are to blame for the problem here. They broke the rules. It's as simple as that. As for U of M to go to all the trouble to reward them for breaking the rules, it just goes to show how sad this world is becoming that we reward bad behavior and scold those who are only trying to enforce the rules.
Cathy Donaldson August 29, 2012 at 11:48 AM
Bryan, I have to agree with Jen on this one. When I first read the article about this boy, I also thought it seemed a little silly. But then, common sense kicked in. The parents were given the dress code rules from day one. Whatever their reasons, it is their rules. The boy was not expelled or punished for wearing the shirt. If one person was told it was ok to break the rules, then why shouldn't everyone be able to do the same? There are always "those parents" that seem to think the rules aren't made for them, and it isn't helping the child either. Then people wonder why high schools have such trouble enforcing any sort of dress code. There are also people who take flash pictures or videos at dance recitals, school plays, etc. when told it is not allowed. Since when does everyone get to decide which rules (or laws) they can and cannot follow? If everyone acted this way, it would be very hard for school officials to enforce anything. I also was a little disappointed in the way U of M choose to react to the situation.
Chris Barton September 01, 2012 at 04:32 PM
I'm Cooper' Dad....I would love to agree that we both knew the rules and were fully aware of them. However, they have never been enforced and every day after the rule was enforced on my son, kids were coming out of the school in Oklahioma city Thunder shirts. (also against the rule) The rule, unless followed for all, is no longer rules and then becomes the subjective opinion of the person in charge that day. Ben Franklin said those who give up a little liberty to obtain security deserve neither liberty or saftey. The rule is obsurd and anyone with even a little sensability would agree. Chris Barton
Bryan Bentley (Editor) September 02, 2012 at 04:26 PM
Mr. Barton, Could you keep us updated as to the decisions made by the Board of Education at their Sept. meeting? Do you and your family have the information about which game Cooper will be attending as well? On another subject, old Ben was a pretty smart fellow. Many of his views have stood the test of time...


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something